Pilgrims’ Pride

A sandwich that's like Thanksgiving in your fist



he Pilgrim. It makes the Uncommon Café worth seeking out, hidden deep as it is inside the Mashpee Commons shopping center. Made with freshly oven-roasted turkey, stuffing, cranberry sauce, and mayo in a panini, the Pilgrim is like Thanksgiving in your fist, and it’s the standout on a long menu of sandwiches with unique combinations of ingredients including gourmet cheeses, prosciutto, garlic mayonnaise, and more. In decent weather, the Uncommon Café is a great place to take a shopping break, at one of the outdoor tables shaded by umbrellas. O’Brien


Opened in 1960 as the New Seabury Shopping Center, Mashpee Commons was redeveloped into its current fake-New England-village incarnation in 1986.

Leave a Reply